Sections
Home » YES! Blogs » Common Security Clubs » No Car, No Problem
 

No Car, No Problem

How one man's choice to live car-free brought him more in touch with his neighbors, his community, and himself.

Car Free Day, photo by Kevin Steele

Bicyclists celebrate "Car Free Day" by setting up a café in a parking spot.

Photo Essay: (PARK)ing Day
One day a year, in cities throughout the country, parking spots take on a whole new meaning. Simply by paying the parking meter and rolling out some grass, residents claim these spaces as public parks—and have their say about how small but precious pieces of urban real estate are used.

Photo by Kevin Steele

On cold rainy days in February, when my shoes are soaked and my legs are damp, I often find myself wondering, “Why did I decide to live without a car?"

Growing up as a teenager in the suburbs, I believed cars were a source of independence. Yet, over the years, I've come to see cars as a symptom of cultural sickness. In college, I decided to save money by not purchasing a car and found that I also escaped worries of shoveling the snow from around its tires, finding parking, and arguing with mechanics. Now, when parents or friends offer me their used vehicles, I turn them down, preferring to avoid the hassle of ownership.

Cecilia Kingman, a minister who convened a Common Security Club in her church, notes that her decision to live with out a car, “always draws curious comments.” Yet she managed to raise two children as a single mother without one.

Kingman's children now say that growing up without a car not only brought their family closer together, but also helped them develop a more relaxed schedule, environmental consciousness, and a strong sense of their own independence and capability. “They learned to take public transportation at an early age, and by middle school could get all over town on their own,” she says.

Lately, it seems, everyone is going “green”–even my mom is eating vegan and taking public transit. Still, as climate change unfolds on a grand scale, we all must wonder if our individual lifestyle choices are really making a significant difference. Although one can worry about paper or plastic, the Union of Concerned Scientists explains that the most influential environmental choices an individual can make boil down to three: Drive less; Eat less meat; Live in smaller, well-insulated homes.

A more radical consciousness raiser for me was reading Ecocities, in which architect and urban planner Richard Register explains how, in addition to environmental problems, cars cause a dislocation of community.

31 Ways call-out31 Ways to Jump-Start the Local Economy

How to make it with less, share more, and put people and the planet first.

As Kingman points out from her own car-free experience, “We ended up supporting a lot of local businesses, because big box stores and malls were much harder to get to. We bought our groceries every few days, which supported a healthier diet. And most of my children’s friends were in the neighborhood, because I couldn't drive them across town for play dates, and that helped us know our neighborhood, which has benefits beyond our own family.”

My friend Danilo Morales grew up in Ecuador with six brothers and sisters. A car was more than his family could afford. As a child, he felt normal taking the bus, as most other families couldn’t afford a car either. Even though he wanted one in high school so he could take his girlfriend to the beach, the idea of going into debt for five to seven years—with little money left over for food and rent—seemed absurd. When he came to the United States, he was shocked to find that a lot of families have one car for every member.

As he began his U.S. job hunt, Morales considered buying a car in order to be able to go after the best available job. Yet he found the stress from the rush hour commute lingered. As he puts it, “When I was young in Ecuador, still finding my identity, a car was attractive in theory. But now I have core principles and I’ve overcome the status mirage of a car. I feel like I am doing something good by avoiding car ownership. Of course, you have to be strategic about where you live.”

As for myself, I am not very rigid about my lifestyle choices. Of course, I still can take taxis—which is recommended on cold, rainy days. I still rent cars to get out of town or to visit relatives. I often borrow cars, if I have big shopping trip to do. And I always accept a ride, if it really isn’t an inconvenience.

I’ve learned some wonderful lessons from living without a car:

  • Commutes are wonderful times to read, and I find the subway relaxing despite the loud roaring and screeching sounds of the wheels on the rails.
  • Walking is when I get all my best thinking done. On a sunny day or summer night, long hikes through the city can be as beautiful as long hikes through the mountains.
  • Shoes are beautiful and important and worth spending money on.
  • Community is vibrantly alive in my neighborhood! Every day, I bump into a neighbor while walking down the street and spend an extra ten minutes chatting–there is a village within the city, and I feel embraced by it.

Any lessons you other car-free folks want to share? I am curious to hear reflections from people thinking of driving less.


Orion KriegmanOrion Kriegman wrote this article for YES! Magazine, a national, nonprofit media organization that fuses powerful ideas with practical actions. Orion coordinates the work of the Great Transition Initiative, a project of the Tellus Institute. He also coordinated the creation of the Urban Ecovillage Network, linking world-wide efforts to create sustainable urban communities. Kriegman holds a Master in Public Policy and Urban Planning from the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University.

Interested?
The Common Security Club Blog
Neighbors are coming together to support each other in hard times by offering mutual aid, taking social action, and learning about the economic forces that impact their lives.

YES! Magazine encourages you to make free use of this article by taking these easy steps. Kriegman, O. (2010, April 02). No Car, No Problem. Retrieved May 16, 2012, from YES! Magazine Web site: http://cms.yesmagazine.org/blogs/common-security-clubs/no-car-no-problem. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License Creative Commons License


You won’t see any commercial ads in YES!, in print or on this website.
That means, we rely on support from our readers.

||   SUBSCRIBE    ||   GIVE A GIFT   ||   DONATE   ||
Independent. Nonprofit. Subscriber-supported.




Reader Comments

A 'less car' lifestyle

Posted by Leslie at Apr 05, 2010 01:42 PM
My husband and I and our 3 children have made a concerted effort to use our cars less for the last 5 years. We've been so surprised that it's been a net benefit to us rather than a sacrifice. Our time on our bikes running errands is cherished family time, and my husband's & my commute is wonderful alone time to think, breathe and observe. We've also paid bills off and saved money, since we're not paying much for parking, gas or maintenance.

Before this experiment, we never would have expected that cars were reducing our quality of life, but they were. Our family chooses walking, biking or transit before driving, even though driving is the supposed "convenient" alternative. It's not the happy alternative, though.

Thanks for your article.

"Less Car" Living

Posted by Orion Kriegman at Apr 07, 2010 01:15 PM
Hi Leslie,
It is amazing how life improves without a car. Of course, in the US, given how spread out we all are, "less car" is more realistic than "no car."

If our society is serious about transitioning to a life-sustaining civilization, then we'll have to tackle the long-term challenge of redesigning our infrastructure and communities. It is sad that railroads, built through hard labor, once criss-crossed this country of ours, and now the few remaining struggle for necessary funding. But that's another story.

Glad to hear your reflections,
Orion

Distance

Posted by Chris at Feb 26, 2011 09:30 AM
Going totally "car less" might be doable in an high population density location, but in a rural area no way. I grew up in a rural part of the New England coast where the closest anything (including the nearest hospital) was over 20 miles away. Once you have children, existing without independent personal transportation in such a situation is completely impractical.

Driving Less/No Car

Posted by Carolyn Knoll at Apr 09, 2010 07:53 PM
I recently moved to Hawaii and have been using public transportation because I DO NOT want to buy a car. TheBus (their name) is terrific!! But, what I am finding very frustrating is that some of the jobs I am applying for require a car. These are administrative jobs which means they are office jobs. No matter what I will not buy a car unless it is absolutely necessary.

No Car, No Problem

Posted by Dean Wynveen at Apr 10, 2010 10:27 AM
There are always problems. I've lived without a car now for 12+ years. I have lots of driving experience under my seat-belt too. I love not having a car. I love to walk. It's in Seattle, so a brisk walk from 1st Ave to 4th, say, to the Library, and I'll be working on aerobics, up-steep-hill all the way. I get well over the number of prescribed steps in every day too. I love my shoes. I often make up songs along the way. I'm slender and fit and my doctor tells me I have the blood presure of a professional athlete. And I do. Though slender, I know the strength of my arms, carrying my groceries from the Pike MKT, or other Food stores, again on a nearly daily basis (always chatting with somebody I know along the way), so I can use a pint size refrigerator. A very small apartment. I eat lots of plants. But alas, always problems. There are not enough of me yet. I'm a very handsome man and its tough to get a date for a Saturday-nite, much less an LTR with my lifestyle. I believe there are people like me out there. It's hard to find them though. But good lord! I can't imagine going back lugging all those tons of steel along with me everywhere I go with invisible stuff coming out the rear end. I got more. But gotta go. Thanks O.K. for the article. It's rare to get a chance to speak about this. Drive less, eat less, live more.

getting a date with a plant and no-car lifestyle

Posted by Anna at Apr 13, 2010 10:31 AM
well, in seattle, I know many people (including me) who date those who are into vegetables and no cars, and seems like you live walking distance from night life, so I wouldn't blame the lack of car.
The only time it is noticeable is when we want to go somewhere like the mountains or the ocean. very little public transit getting to those places, you'd have to be willing to rent a car for those kinds of vacations. or choose different vacations.

Into vegetables rather than cars?

Posted by dean wynveen at Apr 13, 2010 01:26 PM
HAHAHA. Well, glad you found someone like yourself who is into not owning a car. But wait, you didn't say that. It seems like you have a car. If you do. Big difference.

Need more men like you over here

Posted by Lena at May 17, 2010 10:22 AM
I had to respond to your post regarding man living car-free. I absolutely understand the dating aspect & struggle with that myself. Your post was refreshing. I agree with you on health aspects, in better shape than most of 30 something peers!

Signed, single car-free woman in Orange County,CA

No car, no problem!

Posted by Mary at May 25, 2010 07:55 AM
Although I'm a young 20-something, I really enjoyed your post! I'm sorry about the dating problem but you don't really want someone that refuses to try to change their living habits anyway! When you do meet that special lady, you'll be able to appreciate her more because you've learned that they are hard to find! Thanks for being such an inspiration and truly living your life to the fullest!

Carless in Boulder

Posted by Kay Anderson at Apr 14, 2010 07:32 AM
I've only been carless for a couple of months but I'm seeing my community in a whole new way. Yesterday I was dreading a walk to a meeting in fierce winds. Instead of a terrible walk the walk turned into the best part of my day. I must have seen ten different kinds of spring flowers blooming on my 20 minute walk. I'm not sure I'll continue to go carless but for now it gives me time to slow down and enjoy life in a whole new way.

Carless living

Posted by Steve Poss at Apr 14, 2010 10:03 AM
I have tried staying out of the car on weekends, with some success. As the summer heats up down here in South Louisiana, the humidity makes it less attractive, but I still try. Sadly, it is still not safe to go anywhere one wishes, and as Dean noted, not too many women anywhere near my age, 50, want to go out on a bike. It is a weekends only effort, because I work 30 miles from home and bring my kids, so a triple ride on an unsafe highway in the dark is not going to happen anytime soon.

Car-less in America

Posted by red slider at Apr 16, 2010 09:43 AM
A couple of facebook comments on this article associated 'car-less' people with 'bumming rides'. This is was my reply:

Yes, "bumming rides" is probably one feature of going car-less. But if one depends on neighbors for that, perhaps they are also compelled (if they expect to get those rides for very long) to be better citizens in our communities - to be more helpful, sociable and useful so that giving that person a ride is seen as an investment in the community and in one's own life rather than being 'hit-on' for a ride. If the ride-taker happens to be the same person who helped my neigbor put a roof on his house, called the cops when he saw some strangers jumping another neighbors fence, took some hot soup to my grandmother when she was sick, holds the weekly 'back-yard' veggie exchange in his (now) empty driveway, then I might not be viewing his transportation needs as 'bumming'; I might rather be thinking of giving him a ride as the enabling and empowering my whole neighborhood (myself as well) . Maybe we need to re-think how the phrase 'bumming a ride' - a phrase which serves the promotion of car-buying/car-owning - entered our language, associated the car-less condition with people we unconsciously marginalize and judge 'less worthy' and 'less able' to take care of themselves. Perhaps, somewhere in the backseat of the matter we will find the auto industry has been 'bumming a ride' on our attitudes about car ownership for half a century or more?

I would add to that, that 'mini-motor pools' neighbors sharing a common 'vehicle station' with a few cars, perhaps a truck or two, might be a way to cut car use and resource depletion dramatically. For a fraction of the cost of owning an maintaining a care, neighbors could probably have an on-site mechanic (one of the neighbors, themselves?) and a driver/errand-runner as well, for the disabled or elderly in the pool. Something to think about.

no car- still a problem

Posted by Antje Roitzsch at Apr 16, 2010 07:08 PM
I grew up in Germany having a bike for my main transportation and using the bus on rainy days. Now I live in rural Maine and life is very different. No public transportation and everything is spread apart. I would love to share rides with neighbors, but there is no real neighborhood. I actually hardly know the people living up and down the road. I am missing the close community.
In the last week though I have been researching new bicycles. May be the 16 Mile very hilly round trip to town can be done with a better bike.....

Car dilemma

Posted by Katie at Apr 18, 2010 05:47 AM
I have gone the last 10 years without a car. Living in Chicago, DC and now in Baltimore, I have enjoyed exploring each city via walking, biking and public transportation. When I wanted to go to the country, I used a shared car (e.g. Zipcar) or rented a car.

Now my job demands that I have a car for meetings around the state and find myself distraught that I have to buy a car. The irony is that this job advocates green living and here I am buying a car to do that job. So as long as our society continues to expect or require people to have a car - whether for a job or simply because it's EASIER to take a 20 min car drive than 2 hour bus ride - those of us who WANT to remain car free will face tough decisions.

living car-free

Posted by CTD50 at Apr 30, 2010 08:12 PM
September 2004 wasn't the first time I'd called a junkyard to come get a car of mine that had breathed its last -- but it has been, so far, the LAST time I've had to think about it. I've been without a car since then, my commute has routinely been upwards of 18 miles RT, and I pedal that 10-1/2 months out of the year. When surface conditions are too nasty, I take the bus, and what I spend for bus fare all year is less than a month's worth of gas in the car.

I get static from extended family about getting a car -- it's the grown man's responsibility to do, i'm told... yeah, right -- and told I'm neglecting my daughter because I can't get her to the hospital without a car (hasn't been anywhere but the doc's office for check-ups in seven years). My concession to that is to plan to buy a 3-wheeled, 2-seat scooter. It has a partial roof to it, so it's close enough, and I'll likely take it out most often just to keep it in running trim.

But I will continue to pedal; my daughter has an after-school karate class, and has asked me to pick her up in the trailer, now that the weather has broken. Sure -- why not?

It IS a liberating experience.

Car-less

Posted by Joy Nichols at May 28, 2010 05:32 PM
The long waits for buses and commutes allowed me to spend a lot of time reading and studying for classes while attending community college some years ago, which also helped me make good grades. I was a single parent then, and had to do most of my grocery hauls using the city bus, too, which I disliked immensely, but it worked out. Anyone who thinks they can't live without a car, but lives in or near a metro area with a transit system is full of it. It just requires a change of attitude and of lifestyle. One major problem with the bus system, especially in the south is the association of poverty with its use; partly because of that, the system itself is limited. Classism just has to go; everyone should use the bus or subway in their city at least twice a week, something that would improve these systems, especially in the south and help the environment everywhere.

Busing it in the South

Posted by Roger Williams at Jan 08, 2011 02:04 PM
Joy, if you were close by, I would hug you because your comment is right on the money.

I live in South Florida, and I only use my car on the weekends and on Monday evenings to attend a discussion group for Black, GBTQ men.

I use public transit, my bicycle and my feet to do everything else during the week, and you are so right about the perception of people who use the bus. Public transportation is seen as the poor people's transportation.

In college, I remember a colleague deriding what it would cost him to repair his delapidated car, while in the same breath scoffing at me for using public transit to get to class. I will never forget that conversation and the congnitive dissonance that many motorists or auto-dependent people display

I don't care. I take my bus, walk or ride when it is raining, cold of if it is sweltering outside (and I sweat a lot).

But, it can be done. It's all about planning. THAT is also another problem. Many are lazy and don't want to spend the time to plan trips and outings, totally not realizing the tremendous value in planning a simple trip to the beach or to a concert or something like that, particularly if one has children that could learn from the experience of being organized and conscious.

I'm rambling, but thanks for your post.

Cycling is Beautiful

Posted by Dan at Jun 16, 2011 07:21 AM
I live in a small town area that has very little public transportation (and nothing to my work), so I try to cycle. It's 23 miles roundtrip, which is really long when there are headwinds or cold rain or subfreezing temperatures. But I keep doing it, about 50% of the time. I now have a very small electric car for the other times, so that's a transition option as we slowly work back to more local communities and economies.

In the meantime, cycling to work, despite the effort, is well worth it. I enter a very peaceful rhythm on my ride because it has become so automatic (I've logged over 10,000 miles on essentially the same 11 mile route). Yet, far from being boring, what occurred to me today is that I have a huge memory bank of events on my rides over the past few years that fills almost every 100 yard segment of my commute. Some are bad, like a few falls I've had, including one which broke my collar bone. Others were pretty difficult at the time to overcome but satisfying to make it through. Weather extremes: ice storms, snow, wind, and heat come to mind. But continuing through sickness, mechanical issues, fatigue, and social pressure is also satisfying. But most of all there are really good things I get to see and experience on my ride that I otherwise wouldn't. Like feeling the beautiful sunshine on my skin while zipping down the road under my own power. Like the many scenic sunrises, sunsets and pleasant farm vistas I see. Like the other bikers and buggy riders (I live in Amish country) I encounter and wave to. I get to cross a large creek several times and go through a covered bridge, making for some nice ambiance and enhanced animal sightings. Along with all the standard farm animals, I've seen many birds, mostly the pigeons, robins, sparrows, and crows - but the occasional cardinal, goldfinch, and blue heron. Groundhogs, foxes, turtles, snakes, fish, raccoons, and beavers have all graced my eyes with a glimpse while I've been quietly pedaling along. Just today a hot air balloon was preparing to land on a farm I pass on my way to work. I stopped, along with a boy on his bike with a huge smile on his face, and said, "It's not every day you see a huge balloon over your house, eh?" I then took a picture. Not sure I'll remember what to do with that picture, but I have in my head that scene and so many other positive feelings that will continue to give me joy and inspiration to keep me on my bicycle.

People Who Love YES! Find Out Why... Subscribe Today

Personal tools