Sections
Home » YES! Blogs » Sarah van Gelder » Dear Glenn Beck: It’s Not Conspiracy, It’s Courage

Dear Glenn Beck: It’s Not Conspiracy, It’s Courage

Glenn Beck thinks the spread of protests is a little too convenient. But this is what happens when ordinary people discover their power.
— tags:

Glenn Beck has made a startling discovery. People are working together to make change!

Beck used my recent article, “Wisconsin: First Step in an American Uprising?” as a backdrop during his Wednesday show on Fox News, where he talked in dark, hushed tones about the spread of the UK Uncut movement to the United States. “A coincidence?” he asked. Is it a coincidence that citizens of both countries are holding protests in multiple locations on February 26?

Hardly! Organizers of US Uncut have made no secret of the fact that they were inspired by the British upstart group. UK Uncut started when 12 people meeting at a London pub decided they were fed up waiting for “someone to do something” about the fact that, in response to budget shortfalls caused by the financial crisis, the government was planning drastic cuts to public services while big businesses were raking in record profits. “Why don’t we just start?” they wondered. “If we do it, maybe everybody will stop asking why it isn’t happening and join in.”

Is it a coincidence that citizens of both countries are holding protests in multiple locations on February 26? Hardly!

They sat down in front of a retail outlet of a major cell phone company that was $6 billion behind in its taxes. If that company paid up, they argued, all those cuts—to libraries, schools, health benefits, pensions—wouldn’t be needed. The protests spread, eventually shutting down retail stores and banks across the country.

Unlike the Tea Party movement that Beck likes so well, they didn’t have billionaire money behind them. The oil tycoon Koch brothers didn’t bankroll a front group to train and fund them and give them talking points. No, UK Uncut is made up of ordinary people, using social media to coordinate their actions, getting their voice heard in spite of being off the message that the Murdoch media would like us to hear. When news of their success spread to the U.S.—primarily via an article in The Nation by British columnist Johann Hari (reposted here)—Americans with the same concerns were quick to take up the idea, and dozens of decentralized US Uncut groups quickly formed.

Now, MoveOn.org and Van Jones are teaming up in a call for rallies on the same day to protect the American Dream. And the United States Student Association and Jobs with Justice are collaborating (there's that word again!) on a call to defend public benefits.

These sorts of collaborations are not new, and they're not secret. If Beck had been reading YES! Magazine, for example, he would have seen hundreds of examples of groups that form from the bottom up, that work for the benefit of ordinary people, and that collaborate in lots of creative ways. 

No longer isolated and afraid, standing up for what they believe in, and, yes, collaborating, these people know they have power.

Which we think is a good thing. That collaboration is urgently needed at a time when the power balance in the United States is leaning dangerously toward large corporations and Wall Street banks. Because these institutions are formed to increase the wealth of those who already have it, any other goal we might have for our communities, our families, and our future easily gets pushed aside.

Glenn Beck, Fox News video still

Video still from Fox News' Glenn Beck Show

It’s very clear what happens when corporate power and the fixation on short-term profits get too strong. Taxes on corporations and the wealthy get cut, and so money for infrastructure goes away, and our roads, bridges, schools, and universities decline. The pay and benefits of ordinary workers get cut, and they can no longer afford homes, education for their children, or health care. Environmental protection is put on the back burner or simply gutted, and our mountaintops are blown apart (including sites that could be ideal for wind farms that could supply energy for centuries to come). The climate crisis disrupts agriculture, causes floods and droughts, and brings extreme weather events, yet corporations prevent action. Our local economies are sapped of their strength, and regulation that could prevent some of the worst abuses goes away. That leaves us vulnerable to the sort of global economic meltdown that happened in 2008, and that continues to undermine economies everywhere. And the Supreme Court’s Citizens United ruling is just the latest in a cascading series of events that adds still more power to the corporate side of the scale.

This lopsided power makes the events in Wisconsin (and now Ohio, Indiana, Tennessee, and many other states) all the more important. Ordinary people still have power, but only when we talk together and work together.

Wisconsin firefighter, video still by Finn Ryan
We Are Wisconsin

Video: Meet the people making history in Wisconsin.

Beck would like to shift the conversation to one of conspiracies and fear—frankly, I’m not not sure what he’s so afraid of, but it seems to be a rotating list that includes communists, the United Nations, and Muslims. Oh, and our president.

But in Wisconsin, firefighters, teachers, nurses, sanitation workers, and students are rediscovering courage. Look at their faces, and you see fatigue, but also joy. No longer isolated and afraid, standing up for what they believe in, and, yes, collaborating, these people know they have power. And so do the rest of us.


How to get involved:

US Uncut actions targeting Bank of America and others will happen in more than 50 American cities on February 26. Here's where you can find the one near to you, or organize a new action.

Van Jones and MoveOn.org are organizing a February 26 “Rally to Save the American Dream” at noon at state capitals and major cities around the country. Wear Wisconsin colors, red and white.

Student Labor Action Project, a collaboration of United States Student Association and Jobs with Justice, is calling for a national day of action to defend the public sector on March 2nd.


Sarah van Gelder is co-founder and executive editor of YES! Magazine, a national, nonprofit media organization that fuses powerful ideas with practical actions.

Interested?

YES! Magazine encourages you to make free use of this article by taking these easy steps. Gelder, S. v. (2011, February 24). Dear Glenn Beck: It’s Not Conspiracy, It’s Courage. Retrieved May 16, 2012, from YES! Magazine Web site: http://cms.yesmagazine.org/blogs/sarah-van-gelder/dear-glenn-beck-its-not-conspiracy-its-courage. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License Creative Commons License


You won’t see any commercial ads in YES!, in print or on this website.
That means, we rely on support from our readers.

||   SUBSCRIBE    ||   GIVE A GIFT   ||   DONATE   ||
Independent. Nonprofit. Subscriber-supported.




Reader Comments

People Power

Posted by Henny at Feb 24, 2011 05:30 PM
Thank you for offering another balanced, sensible and realistic view of what is taking place in Wisconsin, and with US Uncut (and hopefully more places to come). This is such an inspiration!

People Power

Posted by Duane B at Feb 26, 2011 11:20 AM
Speaking of People Power!!

Last Nov the tax payers in Wisconsin spoke. Elections have consequences.

Gov workers in WIS have had their rights protected for over 100 years by the Civil Service Law signed in 1905 by Gov Robert LaFollette.

The national Tea Party movement IS a grass roots movement - no billionaire money.

Big unions and Soros are the billionaires behind this latest disruption. How come you can see the capitalist billionaires but don't see the unions as a major power player with a questionable agenda?

Wis teachers and state workers pay close to $100/mo each in union dues whether they want to or not; the state collects it for the unions and then the unions spend most of those funds attempting to elect officials friendly to them in the next collective bargaining. Is this fair? It is corrupt!

Before you write the next chapter on People Power, please research the imbalance of union power in Wisconsin for over 50 years. This is reformation and correction time.

This is about tax payers being able to self rule - not the unions.

Astroturfer

Posted by mtranchi at Feb 28, 2011 10:54 AM
dollars to donuts this guy's an astroturfer

Koch Bros?

Posted by Tom at Feb 26, 2011 12:48 PM
Oh yeah...and Scott Walker and his body of syncophants are "grassroots movements" too. How hypocrtical of you to conveniently neglect the corporate donations of the Koch Bros to promote their agenda which has nothing to do with "we the taxpayers" unless of course you mean further tax deductions for themselves. Wake the hell up.

Koch Bros?

Posted by Duane B at Feb 27, 2011 09:39 AM
I live in Wisconsin, am a tax payer, and am fully awake. Are you?

Before you judge our right to govern here in the state, consider this:
http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/list.php?type=L
Note that the troublesome Koch Bros are #83 on the list.
Also note the number of unions above them and then number of donkeys on the list.

Kind of changes the facts doesn't it.

Now we know why it is so important for the unions to win in our state and across the country.

Milionaire Culture or Survival?

Posted by Tom at Feb 27, 2011 03:48 PM
Since the Supreme Court ruling of two years ago left electoral contributions a wide open field - if one can't contribute one can't play in the game.

Unions of course must contribute to be considered. As the union movement has shrunk in size (out-sourcing to increase profits for corporations and shareholders) it's become a matter of sheer survival.

The practices advocated by your governor are intended to destroy the union movement - not change it. Without unions we become a nation of WalMart workers.

Tea Party people either don't see this, are indifferent or in fact are wed to the corporate puppet masters whose bidding they do regardless of whether they acknowledge it or not. Tea Party may not "receive" donations from the billionaire class but they're certainly in bed with them.

Frankly, the Tea Party is nothing more than a joining together of fundamentalist thinkers: Religious fundamentalists (see last week's Pew Study of Religon and Society); Political fundamentalism rooted in ignorance of the doctrine of implied powers not to mention the general welfare clause of the constitution; and Economic fundamentalists (all we need is laissez-faire capitalism even though experience, history and the last thirty years have shown it doesn't work)

What's needed is a grassroots movement to build a new economy in the wake of it's destruction of both Republicans and Democrats since Clinton's reign. And if the Tea Party would like to join that - more power to them. If not - battle lines are now being drawn - right, left and center.

Union's Electing Their Own Bosses or ??

Posted by Duane B at Feb 27, 2011 06:26 PM
Wisconsin originated all this labor protections over the last 70 years. Experiment over and deemed a failure. Time for a new model to correct this 50+ year mistake.

Did you look at the list of top 100 donors? It is dominated by unions.
The public unions elect their liberal bosses and then we end up with total compensation we can't afford.

The voters of Wisconsin have selected their leaders for the next 2-4 years. We don't want or need outside influence while we give this a go. Sit back and watch how we self rule.

Using stats to lie

Posted by mtranchi at Feb 28, 2011 11:41 AM
Those numbers can't be painting a true overall picture, especially now that businesses can donate unlimited amounts anonymously. If you look at this list,[ http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/indivs.php] for example, you'll find that the biggest donaters from citigroup donated 1.5 times as much to dems than repubs, and donaters from goldman sachs donated twice as much to dems than repubs. I simply can't imagine these people, most of whom have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars in contributions, being democrats. There's got to be back-alley deals going on.

Donation Stats

Posted by Duane B at Feb 28, 2011 12:33 PM
Many large companies donate to the politicians that can help them the most - when Dems are in office, they contribute more to the Dems.

Also if you drill down to the details, you will see that an entity's donations consist of soft and PAC $ AND individuals within the corp that donate $. You can see the top givers inside the corps and the top 5-6 receiving politicians.

As far as I can see this is the most objective and well done source tracking political donations.

So...

Posted by mtranchi at Mar 01, 2011 12:19 PM
So what are you saying? That unions have more control in Washington and all the state governing bodies than banks, the military industrial complex, wall street?

Are you saying that the total compensation package, including retirement, health benefits, etc is not 4% less than comparable private sector employees?

Donation Stats and Compensation

Posted by Duane B at Mar 01, 2011 02:31 PM
Yes - Unions elect/hire their own bosses - www.heritage.org/Research/Factsheets/2011/02/Government-Unions-101-What-Public-Sector-Unions-Wont-Tell-You

and Yes - Total Compensation for Wis public workers is 20% ave more than equal private workers. See Inflated Government Pay at:
http://www.heritage.org/Res[…]e-Government-Union-Monopoly

Sorry

Posted by mtranchi at Mar 01, 2011 02:49 PM
Not gonna waste my time looking at reports from the Heritage foundation. That's like lending credence to reports funded by the tobacco industry about whether or not cigarettes are detrimental to health. Talk about a sock-puppet foundation.

And you didn't answer my first question. I would say don't bother, but if you can find a report at the Heritage foundation saying that unions are the ones running things in washington, i'll click on that link.

They get less than private sector

Posted by mtranchi at Mar 01, 2011 03:09 PM
No doubt you'll attribute this article to the vast liberal control of the media (how ridiculous, all you have to do is google "which 4 companies own all media," and yeah, I'm sure Murdog is really liberal at heart), but I'll lend more credence to USA Today than the heristooge foundation. http://www.usatoday.com/[…]/2011-03-01-1Apublicworkers01_ST_N.htm

Doesn't include lobbying money

Posted by mtranchi at Mar 01, 2011 01:03 PM
And of course those figures completely ignore lobbying moneis, which they spend to target specific legislation, like the clean air protection act, or the clean water protection act. http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/lobby.php?id=D000000186 They want the u.s. to be another china, dumping raw polution straight into rivers

Lobbying Costs

Posted by Duane B at Mar 01, 2011 02:34 PM
And it does not include the $ spent by unions to organize demonstrations and bus in all. Getting rid of both would be fine with me.

Financial status

Posted by mtranchi at Mar 01, 2011 02:53 PM
Are you in the top tenth of one percent of income earners hoss? If so, then what you say makes sense, if not, which is worse, to pity someone or to have no respect for them or their opinion? Doesn't matter, I feel both towards you.

how they're hiding contributions

Posted by mtranchi at Mar 01, 2011 01:22 PM
Silly me, here's how they're hiding their contributions http://www.boingboing.net/[…]/infographic-on-the-r.html. Their front group Americans for Prosperity gave $50,000,000.- in campaign contributions for the 2010 election alone.

Hiding Contributions

Posted by Duane B at Mar 01, 2011 03:52 PM
Would be easier to follow your logic if your link worked!!
The Right learned that from the 2008 donor aggregators that the Left used big time to elect Obama. Consider it a compliment.
Also consider how Soros launders his donations thru 100's of organizations.

No Dem/Repub

Posted by mtranchi at Mar 01, 2011 06:11 PM
There is no democrat/republican, they're all beholden to the corporations. As far as Soros goes, I find him a bit suspect. Odd that he would decide to stage rallies on the same day as u.s. uncut staged their first set. Which affects the bottom line of mega-corps more, public sector union rights or tax loopholes that enable them to pay little or no taxes? I don't know enough about the man, but i've heard other stuff (can't recall), so for all i know he's a pied piper of sorts, distracting people's attenttion, like the magician, so the important stuff can get done.

People Who Love YES! Find Out Why... Subscribe Today

This Changes Everything portlet ad

David Korten's books Ad

Most Popular
10 Things Science Says Will Make You Happy
     Oct 31
Living Large in a Tiny House
     Oct 31
A Month Without Monsanto
     Aug 24
Can There Be “Good” Corporations?
     Apr 16
8 Ways to De-Corporatize Your Money
     Apr 11

Get Back Issues of YES!

 
Personal tools