Sections
Home » YES! Blogs » Shannon Hayes » Saying Goodbye to the P.O.

Saying Goodbye to the P.O.

Thousands of small-town post offices are on notice for closure. Radical homemaker Shannon Hayes on what that will mean for the communities who love them.

post office by Matt Wakeman

Budget shortfalls are causing many small local post offices to be closed.

Photo by Matt Wakeman

Yesterday I walked into my local post office to mail a few boxes of books. Cathy, our postmaster, looked exhausted.

“Is it happening?”

“Looks like it.”

For years now, our beloved West Fulton Post Office has been a tenuous neighbor. West Fulton was once a bustling community. Less than 100 years ago, it was called Sapbush Hollow, home to two hotels, a community theater, and a few shops. Eventually we were annexed into the next town, and we lost our name, too. The hotels no longer exist; nor do the shops. But we still had our community identity, even if the name was changed. And we still had our post office.

“Economics” comes from the Greek word, oikonomia, referring to the management of the household, or household affairs.

Then Cathy received official word that we are “being studied for closure,” along with 3,653 other post offices across the country (many in rural communities like ours), as part of a major restructuring of the cash-strapped U.S. Postal service. Rumor has it that “being studied for closure” is a joke—that it simply means your post office is done.

“I feel like I’m losing a member of my family,” Cathy said. She started to cry. So did I.

There are plenty of arguments in favor of the closure. The post office had an $8.5 billion shortfall last year. Email has replaced first class letters. The USPS would argue these small community post offices aren’t efficient. They don’t make economic sense.

And maybe they don’t, so long as the definition of “economic sense” is interpreted merely as an efficient transaction of U.S. currency. “Economics,” however, comes from the Greek word, oikonomia, referring to the management of the household, or household affairs. And in that respect, our small community post offices are among the most efficient economic institutions I know of. 

The post office is where we go to locate or report a lost pet, to discuss books and newspaper articles, to announce a garage sale, to spread the word if someone in the community is in need of help.

Any of us who have the good fortune to use a post office that is not in the center of a business hub knows that their value far exceeds the transactions in the register. The customer service is often fantastic, and they are far easier to use than the urban postal centers or the USPS website.

But there’s more to it than that.

With every member of our hamlet having daily transactions at this office, it is the community center. The post office is where we go to locate or report a lost pet, to discuss books and newspaper articles, to announce a garage sale, to spread the word if someone in the community is in need of help. It is a place to debate local politics, to find out about road conditions from anyone who’s been to town, to announce a pancake breakfast, to swap zucchini recipes or information about the latest vegetable blight.

Radical Homemakers Book Link

Radical Homemakers: Reclaiming Domesticity from a Consumer Culture

By Shannon Hayes
Left to Write Press, 2010, 300 pages, $23.95.
Support YES! when you buy here from an independent bookstore.

I grew up with the West Fulton Post Office as a key fixture in my social circle. Two and a half miles from my family’s farm, I’d ride my bike there to secretly meet up with boyfriends, or to send post-marked break-up letters. Years later, after meeting my future husband, I proudly introduced Bob to our local P.O., persuading him that it was one of the best justifications for moving from Maine to West Fulton, New York.

No mail delivery is available on the road where we now live, but two weeks after Bob and I bought our house and he lost his job, vegetables and kind notes were brought to our doorstep by neighbors, one of the courtesies of post office gossip. That first Christmas we shared together—with a new mortgage and no job—Mary Ann, the postmaster at that time, presented us with our very first tree ornament, taken from her own Christmas tree, to wish us luck and encourage us to stay in our community.

The first chickens my mom and dad raised out on pasture came across that postal counter, inaugurating our family farm’s transition into a viable, community-centered business. When Bob and I began self-publishing our books and shipping them through the post office, Mary Ann would announce to all the neighbors each book release, then proudly stamp each package with her own personal mark: “West Fulton PO: Thanks for doing business in the middle of nowhere!” Recognizing the post office’s status as the gathering spot, Mary Ann even brought in a coffee pot and kept it percolating all day long for anyone who wanted to sit for a while.

When Mary Ann retired and Cathy came to join us, she also quickly took up an honored place in the community. She kept track of the credit cards Bob and I would leave behind in our flutter of chaos trying to mail out books and deal with newborns, then toddlers, then small children. She taught Saoirse how to address, stamp, and mail her first letter, and was the first person with whom our young daughters began conducting money transactions. She walks the roads with her camera during her lunch hour, and shares pictures of the wildlife she sees. When Bob and I sold our last car, we didn’t need to bother with the Want Ad Digest or Craisglist. We went to the post office, and the car was sold in less than a week. The West Fulton post office has delivered us homes for stray cats, honey and meat customers, readers, gifts, and many friends. True to the original meaning of the word, it has been critical to our household economy, and to that of our neighbors.

We have relished our certified status as a community by way of an official postmark.

And now, we are being studied for closure. The postal service argues that we can go online to print postage, that there are other post offices nearby. Heck, UPS says they’ll even come right to my door to pick up packages, saving me the drive. But this is about something more important than efficiency. The West Fulton P.O. was ours.

We’ve lost our community name. We’ve lost our hotels, our shops, and our community theater. In the absence of these historical features, we’ve loved our post office and we’ve supported it as best we could. But despite our wishes, it will likely be taken away, too. In West Fulton—and in many other places that have long supported our small post offices now slated for closure—we have relished our certified status as a community by way of an official postmark. We will now have to focus on other ways to adhere without our official community stamps. But until the day the final decision is made, please keep supporting them. And thanks for doing business in the middle of nowhere.


ShannonHayes_biopicShannon Hayes wrote this article for YES! Magazine, a national, nonprofit media organization that fuses powerful ideas with practical actions. Shannon is the author of Radical Homemakers: Reclaiming Domesticity from a Consumer Culture, The Grassfed Gourmet and The Farmer and the Grill. She is the host of Grassfedcooking.com and RadicalHomemakers.com. Hayes works with her family on Sap Bush Hollow Farm in Upstate New York.

Interested?

  • Click here to read more of Shannon's blogs about life as a radical homemaker.
  • Meet the Radical Homemakers
    How families are achieving ecological, social, and economic transformation... starting under their own roofs. 
  • Live Dangerously: 10 Easy Steps
    When Shannon Hayes made a list of easy steps for becoming a radical homemaker, she didn't realize just how revolutionary they were.
YES! Magazine encourages you to make free use of this article by taking these easy steps. Hayes, S. (2011, August 09). Saying Goodbye to the P.O.. Retrieved May 16, 2012, from YES! Magazine Web site: http://cms.yesmagazine.org/blogs/shannon-hayes/saying-goodbye-to-the-p.o. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License Creative Commons License


You won’t see any commercial ads in YES!, in print or on this website.
That means, we rely on support from our readers.

||   SUBSCRIBE    ||   GIVE A GIFT   ||   DONATE   ||
Independent. Nonprofit. Subscriber-supported.




Reader Comments

post office closures

Posted by Karen at Aug 13, 2011 03:52 AM
I welcomed reading this article. Last evening at diner we were discussing this very same topic. It is sad and like you stated also they are indeed the backbone of small in the middle of nowhere hubs for the folks that live in rural places. The internet is convenient and UPS does make it easier, but the post office is part of America. What can we do. I thought a campaign is what might help. Reminding folks about the post office and what it sacrificed to be for us all. I think if 227,786, 236 folks 18 and over would just buy a 44 cent stamp and mail, even a hand written or colored note, thank you to somebody or a I love you to another that would raise 90+ million dollars. It might work and it is a good idea. Just my 44 cent worth on the topic. I will re-post your article on FB today and tweet it too.
Thanks for the behind story from your neighborhood.

thank you

Posted by s.d. at Aug 15, 2011 01:43 PM
Karen, as a postal employee for over 26 years now, I want to thank you for your great idea. It's wonderful to know that some people out there care about us and what we do for them.

Reply to your thanks for the good idea

Posted by Karen Nardella at Aug 15, 2011 04:23 PM
I posted my idea onto FB and Twitter, maybe the UPO could do something asking folks on a larger scale. Thus reaching the masses without spending a lot or any money. They could be creative and use FB, Twitter, You Tube and other sites. It could work. It could make a difference in a big way. I am rooting on this end for a postitive result. Keep me posted. Thanks for acknowledging my response.

rural post offices for closure ?

Posted by JOSE at Aug 16, 2011 07:57 AM
THE REASON THE POST OFFICE WANTS ALL RURAL POST OFFICES CLOSE ? IS BECAUSE THEY DON'T MAKE MONEY.. DO UPS--FEDEX HAVE OFFICES IN EVERY TOWN LIKE THE POST OFFICE DOES ? NO.. THE POST OFFICE GOAL IS TO LOOK LIKE UPS.. OFFICES THAT DON'T MAKE ANY MONEY ? SHOULD BE CLOSE. WHY THEY WAITED SO LONG TO DO IT IS BEYOND ME.. 37 YEAR RETIRED MAIL MAN.

rural post offices for closure ?

Posted by JOSE at Aug 16, 2011 07:57 AM
THE REASON THE POST OFFICE WANTS ALL RURAL POST OFFICES CLOSE ? IS BECAUSE THEY DON'T MAKE MONEY.. DO UPS--FEDEX HAVE OFFICES IN EVERY TOWN LIKE THE POST OFFICE DOES ? NO.. THE POST OFFICE GOAL IS TO LOOK LIKE UPS.. OFFICES THAT DON'T MAKE ANY MONEY ? SHOULD BE CLOSE. WHY THEY WAITED SO LONG TO DO IT IS BEYOND ME.. 37 YEAR RETIRED MAIL MAN.

Doesn't make sense

Posted by Kathy at Aug 13, 2011 04:55 AM
I can't figure out why the USPS is targeting rural PO's for closure. I live in upstate NY, near a small city. In less than a 5 mile radius there are 5 post offices. I live closer to a neighboring town's post office than I do my own. Surely it would make more sense to eliminate some of the redundant PO's in metropolitan areas rather than the isolated rural ones.

Compliment on PO Closing Blog

Posted by Merritt Scott Miller aka Mishka at Aug 14, 2011 10:55 AM
Shannon, I thought you did an outstanding job with this and I'm referring my own readers to it. Thank you very much for this. Merritt Scott Miller, EIC, The Northstar Journal http://nsjour.wordpress.com\

Post Office Closing

Posted by Retired 44 at Aug 15, 2011 06:49 PM
The writer presents some solid facts about keeping this Post Office or any rural office open. But please spare me the argument:

"With every member of our hamlet having daily transactions at this office, it is the community center. The post office is where we go to locate or report a lost pet, to discuss books and newspaper articles, to announce a garage sale, to spread the word if someone in the community is in need of help. It is a place to debate local politics, to find out about road conditions from anyone who’s been to town, to announce a pancake breakfast, to swap zucchini recipes or information about the latest vegetable blight"

These small Post Offices can no longer be sustained just to conduct a social outlet...Suggest all these nice exchanges be done at the local dinner, coffee shop, library or bar...

"A Pancake Breakfast" Give me a break!

closures

Posted by doug at Aug 16, 2011 12:03 AM
As I work there for a long time, it's all about wasted money. There's too much management in my plant, riding in golfcarts, really doing nothing. Whats even worse is maintenace riding in golfcarts, custodians I mean doing nothing not even emptying our trashcans, clear up all this waste and I can see a future but I'm already sure their going to blame it on small post offices, which is garbage

WASTE IN THE PO.

Posted by JOSE at Aug 16, 2011 08:13 AM
I BEEN A MAIL CARRIER FOR 33 YEARS AND 4 YEARS IN THE MARINES.I RETIRED THIS YEAR.. I CAN TELL YOU THAT IN MY OFFICE 34 ROUTES THE WASTE IS BIG, 4 CUSTODIANS FOR A SMALL BUILDING . ONE CUSTODIAN THE GUY IN CHARGE DOESN'T DO ANYTHING BUT KISS UP TO THE BOSSES WHILE THE OTHER 4 TRY TO LOOK BUSY.. THAT IS JUST IN MY OFFICE.. WE HAVE A CLERK SUPERVISOR TO SUPERVISE 6 CLERKS THAT DON'T NEED SUPERVISION.. ON THE CARRIER SIDE WE HAVE POSTMASTER--ONE FULL-TIME SUPERVISOR AND SOMETIMES 2 FULL-TIME 204-B'S.. A 204--B IS AN ASSISTANT SUPERVISORS .. WHEN CARRIERS LEAVE FOR THE STREETS AT 9:30 THEY HAVE NOTHING TO DO ALL DAY. THEY SEAT AROUND TALKING AND KEEPING EACH OTHER A WAKE.. AND THAT IS ONLY IN ONE OFFICE.. BIG TIME WASTES. jOSE FROM ILLINOIS.

usps

Posted by george berthiaume at Aug 16, 2011 06:46 AM
instead of closing small offices close district offices last year postal service closed 7 of their over 79 district offices saving 1billion ayear close35 more districts and save 5billion ayear

comment on PO closure

Posted by cyndi kershner at Aug 20, 2011 11:18 AM

I agree with the other poster who called out the comments about the post office as community center. Seems like not such a good reason to spend tax dollars. Pretty cool that they will come to your doorstep to pick up your packages for you, I live in the city and they won't do that for me!

Sorry for your loss, but honestly doesn't seem like that big of a deal compared with the stress others are experiencing due to the recession.

USPS ok

Posted by VoteOnPaper at Aug 24, 2011 09:41 AM
It is my understanding that the USPS is doing just fine financially, it's the requirement that they be able to fund the next 75 years of retirement in the next 10 years that is causing the problem.

As the daughter of a postal carrier, I can appreciate knowing that earned benefits will be available. This requirement, however, is taking a toll on our village lifelines - our small post offices.


"The USPS's current $8 billion deficit is mainly a result of a 2006 congressional directive that the USPS pre-fund all retiree benefits for the next 75 years within 10 years, a financial burden no other agency shares [or any corporation for that matter]."

re: rural post offices

Posted by Lori at Aug 26, 2011 02:57 AM
I live in a rural area and rarely use the post office that delivers the mail to my home, which happens to be one of the many that are slated for closure. The town it is located in is barely a town. All it is is a grain elevator, a church, an elementary school that is part of a larger nearby town's district, and several homes. It is less than three miles from one much larger town, about 3-4 miles from another larger town, and about 10 miles from another. I regularly use one of the Post Offices in one of those larger towns and my hope is that the one I am using regularly ends up being the one delivering my mail because I am quite certain that this one that presently delivers my mail being slated for closing closes. A community center? Hardly! When I have used the post office that delivers my mail on those very rare occasions, the post-person on duty seems like a stranger to me (It has had several different postmasters in the last ten years), and I have never seen any other customer use it. I agree with those commenters who say that if we want communities to gather and discuss their livelihoods with others, than we should support the usage of actual community centers, not another post office. I will not miss my post office when it closes. Besides, another reason for the demise of the postal service is the environment. All that wasteful paper being used to communicate is polluting our planet. While computer materials can be wasteful, to a degree, I would much rather communicate my correspondence on a computer than waste paper doing so. For those concerned about people not being able to afford computers and internet access, we should be advocating for better access and affordability to the internet for all humans to use in their own homes and other spaces such as shelters. The internet is now a requirement of our livelihoods, like it or not. Still don't believe me? Visit your over-crowded, over-burdened, and severely under-funded local public library. Let's move on ahead, shall we, and realize the obsolescence and out-datedness of the postal service.

Not Obsolete yet...

Posted by mo at Sep 27, 2011 01:08 PM
As both a part-time Rural Agriculturist and a Big Metropolis dweller, I do NOT believe the US postal service or ALL of our rural post offices are in any way obsolete or outdated and I would hate to think that the correspondence and shipping of an entire nation rests solely in the hands of private-for-profit entities or the on the vagaries of wires and wireless signals! Despite the promises of the technological age, so far it is not yet — nor do I see it in the very near future as being — a "paperless" world. I still believe that one of the responsibilities of our government is to SERVE the people. Yes, there is far too much waste in almost ALL government programs, but each and every individual Gov't Employee holds some responsibility for that. If you are going to serve the people and take their tax dollars, then do it responsibly. While they serve their purpose, I can only shudder at the thought of UPS and FedEx, and other such companies who would jump into the game should the USPS be abolished, being the sole means by which we ship our consumer goods and personal papers across the country. They are answerable only to their share holders and CEOs and will not necessarily keep in mind the needs of the people at large in re prices, areas served, and services offered. I believe that a viable, sustainable and service-oriented USPS is as vital to the health and spirit of this nation as it was during the days of the Pony Express — although it will, of course, look and operate differently, the mission is still basically the same. Perhaps when they do truly invent the "transporter" as envisioned by Star Trek, we can consider the US Postal Service to be antiquated.

Post Offices - Societal Cost

Posted by Walt at Sep 17, 2011 04:57 AM
Again, what is not being considered is the overall impact. ALL consolidation of services increases the requirement for transportation and transportation INCREASES personal AND societal costs. Every person that walked, rode a bike or drove a short distance to send a package will now have to drive a longer distance, or call UPS and pay their transportation costs instead of the one or 2 mailmen and one truck in the rural post.

Importance of Rural Post Offices

Posted by Olivia at Sep 27, 2011 12:38 PM
I understand that USPS needs to change its game in order to stay out of the red. However, I agree with other comments that redundant post offices in metro areas should get the boot. All the metro post offices I visit always have several counters that are closed. Let's trim the number of city branches, up the productivity, and leave rural post offices alone. My parents live in a small town and they use the post office every day to check their PO box and several times a week to mail packages from their small business. It would be hard for them to drive to a bigger city to do those daily tasks. Small towns have a greater need for their post office than cities do, even if they have a smaller volume of mail

People Who Love YES! Find Out Why... Subscribe Today

Personal tools