Sections
Home » New Economy » The Story of Broke

The Story of Broke

Is it true that the U.S. can no longer afford to take care of its residents the way it once did? Annie Leonard takes on the "we're broke" myth in this 8-minute video.

The Story of Broke

"America isn't broke—it's broken," read one protest sign at an Occupy Wall Street site. Not long ago, of course, the conversation in Washington, D.C. was all about how "broke" the nation was—too broke, some politicians argued, to pay its obligations to creditors, much less provide basic services for its citizens. The fight over the debt ceiling is on hold, for now, but the Super Committee is still considering massive cuts to the social safety net, based on the argument that the United States can no longer afford to take care of its residents the way it once did.

But is it true? "Every time I looked at ways make our communities healthy, sustainable, and just, I kept coming up against 'nice idea, but we're broke,'" says Annie Leonard, (creator of The Story of Stuff, The Story of Cap & TradeThe Story of Cosmetics, The Story of Bottled Water, The Story of Electronics, and The Story of Citizens United). "So I thought it was time to get to the heart of this argument."

The Story of Broke is an 8-minute video explanation of what she found. "It turns out this whole 'broke' story hides a much bigger story—a story of some really dumb choices being made for us—choices that actually work against us," explains Leonard. "The good news is that these are choices, and we can make different ones."

 

 

Interested?

  • How to Liberate America
    How is it that our nation is awash in money, but too broke to provide jobs and services? David Korten introduces a landmark new report, “How to Liberate America from Wall Street Rule.”
  • Occupy Wall Street's Moral Ground
    Much of the Occupy movement’s power comes from a simple moral message: It’s wrong to wreck the world. It’s wrong to wreck the health and hopes of others.
  • 10 Ways to Support the Occupy Movement
    There are many things you can do to be part of this growing movement—and only some of them involve sleeping outside.

 

YES! Magazine encourages you to make free use of this article by taking these easy steps. brooke. (2011, November 07). The Story of Broke. Retrieved May 22, 2012, from YES! Magazine Web site: http://cms.yesmagazine.org/new-economy/the-story-of-broke. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License Creative Commons License


You won’t see any commercial ads in YES!, in print or on this website.
That means, we rely on support from our readers.

||   SUBSCRIBE    ||   GIVE A GIFT   ||   DONATE   ||
Independent. Nonprofit. Subscriber-supported.




Reader Comments

Excellent article!

Posted by Elizabeth at Nov 10, 2011 12:49 PM
Thanks for sharing this video! I loved the one about "Stuff" and had no idea they'd produced a new one (that is also excellent!) that is so relevant to the Occupy Wall Street movements that I am also 100% in support of!

Editor's Note

Posted by Christa Hillstrom at Nov 11, 2011 05:51 PM
Thanks Elizabeth! You might also be interested in these other videos produced by the same people:
The Story of Citizens United
http://www.yesmagazine.org/[…]/the-story-of-citizens-united
The Story of Electronics
http://www.yesmagazine.org/planet/the-story-of-electronics
The Story of Cosmetics
http://www.yesmagazine.org/planet/the-story-of-cosmetics
The Story of Bottled Water
http://www.yesmagazine.org/[…]/the-story-of-bottled-water
The Story of Cap and Trade
http://www.yesmagazine.org/[…]/the-story-of-cap-and-trade

Thanks!

Posted by Tess at Nov 12, 2011 09:35 AM
I will definitely be checking those out!

Is America Broke?

Posted by RW at Nov 28, 2011 10:13 PM
I have a very Right leaning friend who I debate issues like this with. I need some help. He is in disagreement that it is the role of the government to take care of its citizens and asks to be shown where in the Constitution this is stated. Here is his reply to this Yes article which I had sent to him:

Show me where the Founders and original American states or citizens said it was the American nations" job to do this: "...provide basic services for its citizens." (from the Yes article)
 
I'd love to see it. I know some in America tried it and failed miserably every time:
 

New Harmony: Scottish industrialist and idealist Robert Owen bought the Rappite village of Harmony in Indiana, and used it to test his theories of property, education, co-operative manufacture, and higher culture. The experiment persisted from 1825 to 1827 when it broke down in factional disputes, though even long afterward, or perhaps even today, New Harmony is an unusually interesting town. Josiah Warren and Frederick Evans, later Shaker elder, were resident, and Frances Wright blew through town in her bustling about. There were other Owenite settlements, notably at Yellow Springs, Ohio.

Nashoba: 1826-30. A community for freed slaves and white experimenters founded by the amazingly cool English freak Frances (Fanny) Wright near Memphis, Tennessee. Accusations of miscegenation and local hatred and Wright's removal for fund-raising purposes closed the place down. This sucker is hard to imagine in its extreme courage. 1828 has Wright delivering a July 4 address in New Harmony, and visiting Josiah Warren in Cincinnati. Warren remains a staunch feminist throughout his life, while later rejecting the idea of "free love."

Brook Farm: a transcendentalist community founded by George Ripley in 1841. Adorned by very smart people doing physical labor and playing music and writing poetry, including Hawthorne. Emerson and Bronson Alcott participated from the fringe. Emerson called Brook Farm "an age of reason in a patty-pan." Made a transition to Fourierism in 1844, after which, like any decent Fourierist experiment, it disintegrated.

Fruitlands: extremely small transcendentalist community (or house) established in Harvard, Massachusetts by Bronson Alcott in 1843. It fell apart after seven months, among other things, in the struggles between the English reformer Charles Lane - a fanatic who was pushing a vegan ("Pythagorean") diet, celibacy, and many other ascetic disciplines - and Alcott's wife and daughters. Louisa May Alcott fictionalized the situation in her story "Transcendental Wild Oats."

Fourierist Phalanxes: Charles Fourier proves that all these folks lived in an era when a man could sit in his garret in Paris hallucinating, write it down, and call it science. This was also Pearl Andrews's approach to empirical investigation: an a priori science based on introspection into the mind of an eccentric. Fourier had a utopian plan to organize the whole world into big old "phalanxes," which looked something like Versailles. The American experiments included La Reunion near Dallas, Texas and the North American Phalanx - probably the largest and most successful Fourierist project - in Monmouth County, NJ (1841-56), but it too eventually failed due to human nature.

People Who Love YES! Find Out Why... Subscribe Today

Personal tools